When Springs Are Not Just Catalog Items
Most engineering design projects use springs selected from a catalog. That works well when standard sizes and rates meet your requirements. But the mechanical designer who understands spring design from first principles is far better positioned to verify catalog selections, troubleshoot spring failures, and design custom springs when off-the-shelf options are inadequate. This guide covers the three main spring types — compression, extension, and torsion — with the key equations, material considerations, and practical checks you need.
Compression Springs: The Baseline Case
A helical compression spring is the most common spring type. It stores energy when compressed axially. The key design parameters are:
- Wire diameter (d) — the cross-sectional diameter of the spring wire
- Mean coil diameter (D) — measured from wire center to wire center across the coil
- Number of active coils (Na) — the number of coils that deflect under load (end coils that are ground flat are inactive)
- Free length (Lf) — the uncompressed length
- Spring rate (k)
Spring Rate Formula
The spring rate (stiffness) of a helical compression spring is:
k = (G × d4) / (8 × D3 × Na)
where G is the shear modulus of the wire material (approximately 79,000 MPa for steel). A stiffer spring comes from a larger wire diameter, smaller mean coil diameter, or fewer active coils.
Spring Index and Stress Correction
The spring index C = D/d is a critical parameter. A low spring index (below 4) makes the spring difficult to manufacture and produces high stress concentrations in the wire. A high index (above 12) makes the spring unstable and prone to buckling. The recommended range is C = 4 to 12 for most applications.
The stress in the wire under a load F is:
τ = (8 × F × D) / (π × d3) × Kw
where Kw is the Wahl correction factor, which accounts for curvature and direct shear effects:
Kw = (4C − 1)/(4C − 4) + 0.615/C
Always apply the Wahl factor when calculating actual wire stress — the uncorrected formula significantly underestimates the stress in the wire at the inner radius of the coil.
Solid Height and Buckling
The solid height Hs = d × Nt, where Nt is the total number of coils (active plus inactive end coils). The spring must never be compressed to solid height in operation — this causes yielding and permanent set. Maintain a minimum of 10–15% clearance between the operating compressed length and the solid height.
For compression springs with a free length to mean coil diameter ratio (Lf/D) greater than approximately 4, buckling under axial load is a concern. Check with the spring manufacturer’s buckling curves or use a guided end condition to prevent lateral instability.
Extension Springs
Extension springs work in tension rather than compression. The coils are wound with initial tension — a small pre-load that holds the coils closed at zero external load. The spring does not deflect until the applied load exceeds this initial tension.
The spring rate equation is the same form as compression springs. The additional parameter is the initial tension Fi, which is set during manufacture and affects the load-deflection curve directly. The total load at a given extension x is:
F = Fi + k × x
The critical stress concentration point in an extension spring is the end hooks, not the body coils. Fatigue failures in extension springs almost always initiate at the hook bend. For fatigue-loaded applications, specify reduced-stress hooks (a loop with a larger bend radius) and check the bending stress at the hook cross-section explicitly.
Torsion Springs
A torsion spring resists angular deflection rather than linear deflection. The spring body is loaded in bending — not torsion, despite the name — and the wire cross-section is in bending stress, not shear stress.
The angular spring rate is:
kθ = (E × d4) / (10.8 × D × Na)
where E is the elastic modulus (approximately 207,000 MPa for steel). Note that this uses E (Young’s modulus), not G, because the wire is in bending.
The bending stress in the wire is:
σ = (32 × M) / (π × d3) × Ki
where M is the applied moment and Ki is the inner fiber stress correction factor: Ki = (4C2 − C − 1) / (4C × (C − 1)).
One important practical point: as a torsion spring deflects, its mean coil diameter changes, which also changes its free length. Design the shaft or housing to accommodate this change.
Material Selection Summary
| Material | Max Temp (°C) | Key Property | Typical Use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hard-drawn wire (ASTM A227) | 120 | Low cost, general purpose | Non-critical applications |
| Music wire (ASTM A228) | 120 | Highest tensile strength | High-stress, small springs |
| Chrome-vanadium (ASTM A232) | 220 | Good fatigue and elevated temp | Engine valve springs, automotive |
| Chrome-silicon (ASTM A401) | 245 | High fatigue life | Highly cycled, elevated temperature |
| Stainless 302/304 | 260 | Corrosion resistance | Food, chemical, outdoor |
| Inconel (718) | 550 | High-temp performance | Aerospace, high-temperature systems |
FAQ
Q: My compression spring is taking a permanent set after a few cycles. What is causing this?
A: Permanent set occurs when the operating stress in the wire exceeds the elastic limit of the material, causing plastic deformation. Common causes are: load higher than designed, insufficient wire size for the load, using the wrong material, or operating at elevated temperature that reduces the yield strength. First verify the actual operating load against the design load, then recalculate the wire stress with the Wahl correction factor. If the stress exceeds approximately 45% of the material’s tensile strength for static loads, redesign with a larger wire diameter or stiffer material.
Q: How do I specify a spring on an engineering drawing?
A: A spring drawing should specify: wire diameter, mean coil diameter, total number of coils, free length, spring rate (with tolerance), surface treatment (e.g., shot-peened, plated), material specification, direction of winding (right or left hand), and end type (closed and ground, open, etc.). Additionally specify the working loads at defined lengths if the spring has performance requirements, such as: Load at compressed length L1 = X N ± Y%.
Q: When should I shot-peen a spring?
A: Shot-peening introduces compressive residual stresses in the wire surface, which significantly improves fatigue life. It is standard practice for compression springs in fatigue-critical applications — valve springs, suspension springs, and any spring that sees cyclic loading at high stress levels. For lightly loaded or static springs, the cost is usually not justified. Specify shot-peening when the cyclic stress amplitude is more than roughly 30–40% of the material’s endurance limit, or whenever the application has a life requirement above 10 million cycles.
コメント