Weld failures are among the most common causes of structural and machinery failures — and they are almost always preventable with correct throat dimension specification and proper allowable stress application.
Welded connections are permanent, load-bearing structural elements that require the same engineering rigor as bolted joints or machined components. This guide covers fillet weld and butt weld strength calculations, effective throat determination, allowable shear stress per AWS D1.1 and ISO 15614, weld group analysis, and worked examples that engineers can adapt directly to their own designs.
Fillet Weld Geometry and Effective Throat
A fillet weld has a roughly triangular cross-section. The weld size w (also called the leg length) is the dimension of the equal legs of the isosceles right triangle. The effective throat te is the shortest distance from the weld root to the weld face — the critical dimension for stress calculation:
te = 0.707 × w
For a 10 mm fillet weld (w = 10 mm), the effective throat is 7.07 mm. The throat area for a fillet weld of length L is: Aw = te × L = 0.707 × w × L. This is the area used in all stress calculations.
Minimum fillet weld size depends on the thicker base metal being joined per AWS D1.1 Table 6.1:
| Base metal thickness (thicker part) mm | Minimum fillet weld size mm |
|---|---|
| Up to 6 | 3 |
| 6 to 12 | 5 |
| 12 to 19 | 6 |
| Over 19 | 8 |
Maximum fillet weld size is the base metal thickness minus 1.5 mm for plates 6 mm and over (to avoid edge burning), or equal to the base metal thickness for plates under 6 mm.
Allowable Shear Stress in Fillet Welds (AWS D1.1)
AWS D1.1 (Structural Welding Code — Steel) specifies allowable stresses for welded connections. For fillet welds, the failure plane is assumed to be through the effective throat, and the stress is treated as shear regardless of load direction:
Allowable shear stress on throat: fv = 0.30 × FEXX
Where FEXX is the electrode classification strength (minimum tensile strength of weld metal). For E70XX electrodes (most common for structural steel): FEXX = 480 MPa (70 ksi). Therefore: fv = 0.30 × 480 = 144 MPa.
For E80XX electrodes: fv = 0.30 × 550 = 165 MPa. Higher strength electrodes provide increased capacity but require qualified welding procedures and may need preheat for base metals above 0.40% carbon equivalent. The matching filler principle states that the electrode strength should equal or exceed the base metal strength — do not over-specify electrode strength without justification, as it can increase crack susceptibility.
Load Direction Effects on Fillet Weld Capacity
AWS D1.1 recognizes that fillet welds loaded transversely (perpendicular to the weld axis) are stronger than welds loaded longitudinally (parallel to the weld axis). For transverse loading, an increase factor of 1.5 applies to the basic allowable stress. However, for simplicity and conservatism, most structural calculations use the basic allowable (longitudinal loading) for all weld orientations. The increased capacity for transverse loading can be invoked when detailed justification is needed, such as when trying to minimize weld size to reduce heat input or distortion.
Butt Weld Strength
A complete joint penetration (CJP) butt weld that is properly executed and examined is considered equivalent in strength to the base metal. No separate weld strength calculation is required — the joint capacity equals the base metal section capacity. For tension loading: Pallow = 0.60 × Fy × Anet, where Anet is the net section area.
Partial joint penetration (PJP) butt welds are treated differently. The effective throat of a PJP weld depends on the joint geometry and welding process. AWS D1.1 subtracts 3 mm from the groove depth for joints where the included angle at the root is less than 60° (groove angle 45° or less), to account for incomplete fusion at the root. The reduced effective throat is used in capacity calculations, and PJP welds are treated as fillet welds for stress purposes: allowable shear on effective throat = 0.30 × FEXX.
Weld Group Analysis
When a load is applied eccentrically to a weld group (not through the weld group centroid), the weld must resist both a direct shear force and a moment. The method of treating the weld group as a line (unit throat approach) simplifies the calculation significantly.
For a weld group treated as a line, the section properties are calculated per unit weld leg (ignoring throat for now). The section modulus Sw and polar moment Jw are calculated for the weld line geometry. Common weld group properties:
| Weld Configuration | Aw | Iw (x-axis) | Iw (y-axis) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Two horizontal welds (each length b) | 2b | 2 × b × d²/2 (d = half spacing) | 2 × b³/12 |
| Rectangle (b × d) | 2(b+d) | d²(3b+d)/6 (about x centroid) | b²(3d+b)/6 |
| Full rectangle outline | 2(b+d) | (d³/6 + bd²/2 + b³/12)… use formula tables | — |
For in-plane eccentric loading (shear V and moment M = V × e):
- Direct shear stress: f’v = V / Aw (per unit throat)
- Torsional shear from moment M: f”v = M × c / Jw (c = distance from centroid to critical weld location)
- Combined: fresultant = √(f’v,x + f”v,x)² + (f’v,y + f”v,y)²
- Required weld size: w = fresultant / (0.707 × fv,allow)
Out-of-Plane Loading and Bending
For welds subject to out-of-plane bending (a bracket welded to a column flange, carrying a moment that tries to peel the weld off the column), the critical weld stress combines bending tension and direct shear:
Bending stress on throat: fb = M / (Sw × te) where Sw is the section modulus of the weld group in bending.
The allowable tension stress on the weld throat for this case is: ft,allow = 0.30 × FEXX (same as shear, per AWS D1.1 for fillet welds). Some references (AISC Design Guide) use an interaction equation: (fb/ft,allow)² + (fv/fv,allow)² ≤ 1.
Fatigue of Welded Joints
Welded joints are highly susceptible to fatigue because weld toes act as stress raisers with effective Kt values of 2 to 4 or higher. AWS D1.1 Annex K (and ASME Fatigue Design Curves) classify welds into fatigue categories A through F based on geometry and loading direction. Category A (smooth base metal, no welds in stress direction) has the highest allowable fatigue stress range; Category E’ (welds with poor geometry, root defects) has the lowest — approximately 5× lower than Category A. For welded structures subject to cyclic loading, always check fatigue life in the design phase using the applicable weld fatigue category.
Worked Example: Fillet Weld for a Bracket
A steel bracket is fillet-welded to a column face with two vertical welds of length L = 150 mm each and horizontal spacing b = 100 mm (weld group is a rectangle 100 mm wide × 150 mm tall). Load: V = 20 kN applied at e = 150 mm horizontal eccentricity from the weld group centroid. Electrode: E70XX. Determine required weld size.
Step 1 — Weld group properties (per unit weld size, treating as line): Aw = 2 × 150 = 300 mm. M = V × e = 20,000 × 150 = 3,000,000 N·mm. Centroid at mid-height. Jw = (2 × 150³/12) + 2 × 150 × (100/2)² = 562,500 + 750,000 = 1,312,500 mm³.
Step 2 — Direct shear: f’y = V / Aw = 20,000 / 300 = 66.7 N/mm per unit weld size.
Step 3 — Torsional shear: c = √(50² + 75²) = 90.1 mm (corner of weld group). f”v = M × c / Jw = 3,000,000 × 90.1 / 1,312,500 = 205.9 N/mm per unit weld size. Components: f”x = 205.9 × 75/90.1 = 171.4 N/mm, f”y = 205.9 × 50/90.1 = 114.3 N/mm.
Step 4 — Resultant: fr = √(171.4² + (66.7+114.3)²) = √(29,378 + 32,756) = √62,134 = 249.3 N/mm per unit weld size.
Step 5 — Required weld size: Allowable for E70XX: 0.707 × w × 144 N/mm² = 101.8w N/mm (per unit length). Required w = 249.3 / 101.8 = 2.45 mm. Per AWS D1.1 minimum size for plate thickness of say 12 mm: minimum = 6 mm. Use w = 6 mm fillet weld.
Conclusion
Weld strength calculations centre on the effective throat area (0.707 × weld leg × length) and the allowable shear stress on the throat (0.30 × FEXX per AWS D1.1). For eccentric loads, treat the weld group as a line, calculate section properties, and combine direct shear with torsional shear vectorially. Always satisfy minimum weld size requirements regardless of calculated demand, and for cyclic loading applications, apply the appropriate fatigue category from AWS D1.1 or ASME fatigue curves to check long-term weld durability.
コメント